RésuméLe degré de consistance d'un objet résulte de ses moyens de résister à l'assaut de l'extérieur.Il y a la consistance des ětres, la consistance des notions et la consistance des valeurs. Une notion peu consistante est celle dont le sens varie d'un discours à l'autre. Une valeur très consistante inspire une conduite indépendante des convenances particulières et favorables à l'accord des esprits.Les problèmes les plus fondamentaux sont des problèmes de hiérarchie selon la consistance et surtout des problèmes de promotion, passage (...) à un degré supérieur .Notion complémentaire: le degré de précarité.ZusammenfassungDer Grad der Konsistenz eines Gegenstandes ergibt sich aus dessen Widerstandskraft gegen äussere Einwirkungen.Es gibt die Konsistenz der Wesen, die Konsistenz der Begriffe und die Konsistenz der Werte. Ein wenig konsistenter Begriff kann je nach der Aussage, die ihn enthält, verschiedenen Sinn haben. Ein sehr konsistenter Wert begründet ein Verhalten, welches unabhängig ist von den besonderen Umständen, sogar wenn sie ungünstig sind für die Übereinstimmung der Geister.Die fundamentalsten Probleme sind diejenigen der Hierarchie bezüglich Konsistenz, und vor allem diejenigen der Beförderung, des Überganges von einer Stufe zu einer höhern .Komplementärer Begriff: Grad der Prekarität.The degree of consistence of an object results from its possibilities of resisting external attacks.There are: the consistency of beings, the consistency of notions and the consistency of values. A notion is not very consistent if its contents vary from one utterance to another. A very consistent value gives rise to behaviour independent of personal conveniency and conductive to the agreement of the minds.The most fundamental problems are those concerned with hierarchy according to consistence, and above all those concerned with promotion, the passing to a higher grade .Complementary notion: the degree of precariousness. (shrink)

Cahier 1 : « Merleau-Ponty. Philosophie et non-philosophie ».E. de Saint-Aubert, La « promiscuité ». Merleau-Ponty à la recherche d’une psychanalyse ontologique ; P. Maniglier, De Mauss à Claude Lévi-Strauss : cinquante ans après. Pour une ontologie Maori ; E. Bimbenet, Sens pratique et pratiques réflexives. Quelques développements sociologiques de l’ontologie..

Sztr la Moraie et les idLes cogfztses. A profios dztne note de M. A. Ledent.

Abordée pair le côté de la morale, on ne voit pas que la philosophie cartésienne soit ce qui a donné à la spéculation moderne son inflexion décisive. Ne renonçant sur aucun point à l’universelle autorité du Sage éclairé par la Science, l’esprit cartésien couronne l’âge classique, inauguré par la science grecque, et dont le postulat fondamental est l’unicité de la valeur. L’esprit moderne est un repli vers la pluralité des valeurs.

M. Dupréel est, avant tout, un moraliste et un sociologue, et sa théorie de la connaissance est, nettement, d'inspiration sociologique. En insérant les problèmes de la connaissance dans la trame de la vie sociale, en raisonnant sur une pensée complète, et non sur une pensée appauvrie et schématisée, M. Dupréel arrive à des conclusions qui sont souvent très proches de celles que le lecteur est habituéà lire dans Dialectica.Je fais précéder les extraits choisis d'indications bibliographiques qui concernent uniquement (...) les travaux dont ces fragments ont été tirés; il ne faudrait donc pas u voir la liste complète des œuvres de M. Dupréel. (shrink)

The target articles in this special section shed new light on the old question whether and how emotions influence action. However, what is missing is a straightforward motivational analysis—considering what we have learned from the science of explaining the “why” and “how” of behavior. I posit that emotions can influence the motivation process and thus action by fulfilling at least three functions: First, being grounded in needs, experienced emotions can function as strong need-like motivational states. Second, anticipated emotions can function (...) as incentives and justify action. Third, emotions can inform about progress in goal pursuit permitting behavior calibration. In summary, there is little doubt that emotions influence action. They can do so because they are hypo-phenomena of motivation. (shrink)

In some young children brought by their parents for diagnosis of acute life-threatening events investigations suggested imposed apnoea as the cause rather than spontaneous occurrence. Covert video surveillance of the cot in which the baby was monitored allowed confirmation or rebuttal of this diagnosis. That parents were not informed of the video recording was essential for diagnosis and we assert ethically justifiable as the child was the patient to whom a predominant duty of care was owed. The procedure also avoids (...) the risk of separation of child from parent on inadequate information. (shrink)

The line of thought from which contemporary Social Science has come forth was occupied with problems of public policy in a way which has since become very much less prominent in the work of social scientists. The classic figures of social thought —Aristotle, Plato, Adam Smith, Montesquieu, Jeremy Bentham, James and John Stuart Mill, Ricardo, Hobbes and Locke, Burke, Machiavelli and Hegel—were all involved in the consideration of the fundmental problems of policy from the point of view of the man (...) who had to exercise power and to make practical decisions. Even where they themselves lived in remoteness from practical affairs the clarification of the standards for the judgment and guidance of public policy was always close to the centre of their attention. The politician's problems, reduced to fundamentals, were their problems. The problem of maintaining order through the prince's exercise of power was the point of departure of classical political philosophy; it was extended by modern liberalism to the maintenance of liberty in a framework of order. Political philosophy was regarded by those who professed it, as a means of enlightening rulers—and citizens—as to the right ends and the approximate means. The great ancestor of modern empirical social research, Sir William Petty, who regarded his task as the quantitative matter-of-fact description of what existed, viewed his problem as set by the prince's need to safeguard and maximise his power. Early economic theory accepted the same task. Even after mercantalism gave way to liberalism, economic theory was still intended to be a guide to policy. (shrink)

Control of wild animals may give rise to controversy, as is seen in the case of badger control to manage TB in cattle in the UK. However, it is striking that concerns about the potential suffering of the affected animals themselves are often given little attention or completely ignored in policies aimed at dealing with wild animals. McCulloch and Reiss argue that this could be remedied by means of a “mandatory application of formal and systematic Animal Welfare Impact Assessment ”. (...) Optimistically, they consider that an AWIA could help to resolve controversies involving wild animals. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the potential of AWIA. We begin by showing how ideas akin to AWIA already play a significant role in other animal ethics controversies, particularly those concerning laboratory animal use and livestock production; and we bring in lessons learnt from these controversies. Then we comment on the suggested development and application of AWIA in the case of badger control. Finally, we discuss the prospects of applying AWIA to other sorts of wild animal controversy. We argue that the AIWA, as developed by McCulloch and Reiss, relies on several dubious premises, including that killing is a welfare issue. Furthermore, we argue that AWIA is unlikely to prevent serious moral disagreements over how to weigh concerns about wild animals against priorities in human health, the health of domestic and farm animals, and biodiversity, but that it may nonetheless serve to limit harms imposed on the wild animals. (shrink)

When the editor invites comment on a response to an analysis of a criticism of a protocol already defended by the author in this journal, the issue is clearly contentious. I will comment briefly on Thomas's paper in this issue of the journal, and look at points of agreement as well as dissent.